DECISIONS
Verdicts requiring ACT, DEFER, or KILL · each shows what's being asked + what happens for each choice · size-rated
Every decision is laid out in five layers. 1) Why this is being asked. 2) What's being asked of you. 3) What happens if you ACT. 4) What happens if you DEFER. 5) What happens if you KILL. Plus a size rating (BIG / MEDIUM / SMALL) so you know how much weight to give it.
// Cover Verdict · fired 07:14
0.94
RANK
Decision Size
MEDIUM
Ship NAEMA Body's weekly pattern-recall feature to Cohort 1 first.
1
What led to thisPerformers Council logged friction on the daily journal — 42% of Cohort 1 users skip days 4-7. Pattern-Spotters independently flagged the same gap from a different vantage 5 days ago. Two councils saw the same problem → high-confidence signal that something needs to ship.
2
What is being asked of youApprove the build and ship of a weekly pattern-recall card that surfaces 3 patterns from the past 7 days without requiring a daily journal write. Architects has the spec. Critics already passed it. Executioner is ready. This decision authorises the build to start today and ship to Cohort 1 (2,000 users) by Friday.
If ACT
Ships to 2,000 users by Friday. Architects routes to Executioner immediately. Two-week measurement window opens.
- Cohort 1 sees new feature by Fri 5pm
- +18% retention forecast (conf 0.82)
- Auditors fires post-ship to verify
- Performers Council tracks usage daily
- 3 dev-days consumed
If DEFER
Returns to queue with 7-day callback. Architects re-pitches with fresh data next week. No build starts.
- Cohort 1 friction continues another week
- Risk of churn rising as Wk2 hits more users
- Architects callback set for 2026-06-03
- Build slot stays available
If KILL
Eulogists logs formal kill report. Revival Gate locks for 90 days. Architects pivots to different friction-fix angle.
- Cohort 1 daily-journal pattern stays as-is
- Architects must find new approach for same friction
- Revival blocked unless new evidence found
- Pattern-Spotters synthesis re-evaluates source
// Next in queue
13 PENDING
Challenge Law 4 (slow-state sacred) — propose quarterly identity-pattern review window
NAEMA Body Apple App Store policy risk — may delay launch by 4-6 weeks
Modus Build 9 (typed-link graph) ready to ship — CF KV scaffold complete
Sydney Agency portfolio Wave 4 — three demos drifted from voice-lock spec
New domain scout — Australian solo-founder AI tooling space
Red-team on Pengu Dashboard v9 social-momentum module — 3 failure modes mapped
Apple App Store policy change Q3 2026 — biometric data handling
Quarterly meaning audit — does the Borg align with the three refusals six months in
Three NAEMA Agency Cohort 1 clients at risk of churn — Week 2 friction
// Decision Impact · what your past calls produced
ACTED · 4 DAYS AGO
23 May
Architects · NAEMA Body onboarding rewrite v3. Approved 3-day rebuild of week-1 user flow.
Impact
Wk1 completion rate jumped from 51% → 72% in first 48h post-ship. 12 new subs in 4 days vs ~5 prior baseline. Auditors verdict: SUCCESS.
ACTED · 9 DAYS AGO
18 May
Heralds · NAEMA Agency Cabramatta outreach push. Approved 200-prospect cold sequence on Cabramatta restaurants.
Impact
14 replies (7% reply rate). 2 contracts closed at $249/mo · MRR up $498. Worf's lead-list quality validated. Loop continues weekly.
KILLED · 14 DAYS AGO
13 May
Renegades · "Rebuild everything as one LLM-native OS". Wild pitch to kill all 6 projects and merge.
Impact
Eulogists logged formal kill. Revival Gate locked until 11 Aug 2026. Lesson extracted: portfolio breadth is feature not bug · cross-project leverage matters.
DEFERRED · 21 DAYS AGO
6 May
Pricers · Test $329/mo aggressive tier on NAEMA Agency. Pushed price ceiling experiment.
Impact
Re-surfaced 2 days ago. Decision pending. Cost of defer: $40-60 missed MRR per slot at upper tier. Pricers re-pitching with new market data this week.